BLUF (bottom line up front): Some advisors found a way to swap low-basis stock for a diversified ETF without paying tax. The IRS just said no, and it applies to past deals too. Traditional exchange funds are unaffected. This is a slightly nerdy dive into the nuance of how ETF portfolios are taxed.

Mutual funds’ year-end tax
At the start of the year, patient mutual fund investors are often surprised to receive a 1099 for taxable gains from their fund. It creates a double punch for long-term holders if the fund was also down for the year. Your investment lost money and you never sold anything, yet you still owe capital gains tax. You patiently watched your statement decline and received a tax bill as an unwanted consolation prize.
When buying or selling a mutual fund, you trade directly with the fund company.1 They are your counterparty. If there are more requests to sell than buy, the fund may need to liquidate part of the portfolio to have enough cash to cover all of the redemptions. Under IRS rules, the net gain from sales throughout the year flows to investors who still own the fund on the record date (usually in December).
ETFs offer a cleaner exit
With an ETF, your counterparties are other investors instead of the fund, and the fund not needing to sell holdings to make redemptions is one of the mechanisms that make ETFs more tax efficient. Finance is full of trade-offs, however. Since the ETF doesn’t control market transaction flows, heavy buying or selling can cause the price to drift from the true value of the underlying portfolio.2 That’s where Authorized Participants (“APs”) help. They are large financial institutions (Goldman Sachs, J.P. Morgan, UBS, etc.) that, when an ETF’s price wanders off, step in, fix it, and pocket a little for the trouble. When a lot of money is flowing into an ETF, it can push the price above the value of the stocks in the portfolio. An AP buys the underlying stocks in the market, delivers them to the fund, and receives a large block of newly created ETF shares, which it sells at the higher price. The difference is its profit. The selling pulls the ETF’s price back in line, and the fund grows.
This also works in reverse. When an ETF trades too cheap, the AP buys up the discounted shares, bundles them into large blocks, and redeems them with the fund. Instead of cash, the fund pays the AP in stocks from its portfolio. The interesting part is that the fund gets to choose which shares to hand over, and it picks the ones with the biggest built-in gains. If the fund bought Apple in 2012 at $20 and again last year at $190, the 2012 shares are what it hands over. To the AP, it’s irrelevant. When the AP receives the stock as payment, the tax basis on the stock is reset to what the AP initially paid for the ETF shares.
Decades before ETFs existed, Congress provided that this type of exchange, an in-kind, on-demand redemption presented to a Regulated Investment Company, is not taxable to the fund. The gains walk out the door, and nothing is passed on to the fund’s holders. The tax isn’t erased; each investor still owes tax on their own gains when they sell. However, they decide when to sell. It’s not that ETF holders avoid tax that mutual fund holders pay. Rather, ETF holders control when tax is paid through when they sell their shares, while mutual fund holders must pay tax whenever the fund sells internally.
Some smart people have an idea
Students of financial markets know that when clever financial professionals and savvy lawyers get together, tax rules can be combined in unexpected ways. As Dr. Ian Malcolm would say: life finds a way.
Under current rules in the Internal Revenue Code,3 contributing highly appreciated assets to an entity generally doesn’t create a taxable event (subject to limits, such as requiring a reasonably diversified portfolio). Combine this with the SEC rules and the tax code4 that allow the fund to pay Authorized Participants in appreciated stock without recognizing a gain, and you have the framework for a powerful tax strategy. Create a new ETF, have investors contribute their highly appreciated stock to seed it, launch the ETF into the market, and further diversify the portfolio through AP in-kind redemptions. While this doesn’t eliminate the tax—as each investor’s shares in the ETF inherit the basis of the stock they contributed—it does permit investors to meaningfully diversify without paying tax. Potentially, an investor could then hold the ETF until death, upon which their heirs receive a step-up in basis5 and can sell without paying tax on gains built up during the original owner’s lifetime. By following a convoluted path through the tax code, investors diversify without involving the taxman.
The IRS says no more
On September 28, the IRS and U.S. Treasury issued Rev. Rul. 2026-20, putting an end to this ETF strategy. While each step may have followed the letter of a specific rule, the IRS, viewing the steps together as a premeditated strategy, sees this as a taxable swap of stock for a diversified portfolio. If it walks like a sale and quacks like a sale, it’s a sale. While a different issue, it’s similar to rules around “constructive sales,” which prevent investors from fully hedging an investment to protect their gains. If you short the same stock you own, or sign a contract locking in today’s price, to avoid the tax bill from selling, the IRS treats it as a sale and taxes you anyway.
As the ruling interprets existing law rather than creating a new one, it applies to transactions already completed as well as future ones. The ruling is specific to corporations. A partnership version, in which an exchange fund is used as a stepping stone into an ETF, is under review, and Treasury has warned new guidance could also apply retroactively.
What still works
This ruling does not address normal ETF operations, including launching a new ETF with stocks it intends to keep, or conventional exchange funds, which Brightward has evaluated in a few circumstances before. While they follow a similar idea, exchange funds stay within the limits Congress set and are still a practical possibility. Investors contribute appreciated stock to a partnership, which must hold at least 20% of its assets in non-securities, typically real estate, and after seven years, each investor receives a diversified basket of stocks that carries over their original tax basis. Unlike an ETF, exchange funds are private placements, limited to accredited investors.6 Most are further restricted to qualified purchasers7 only.
Bottom line
The ruling is a reminder to be cautious with tax strategies promoted online or by product sponsors. Whether a strategy holds up depends on more than stitching together sections of the tax code. Context, intent, and official interpretations matter.
When something seems too good to be true, it usually is. If you hold a concentrated position and wonder what is possible, come talk with us (and loop in your tax advisor), especially if you’ve been offered an ETF-based strategy like this one.
Notes
- In practice, the custodian, such as Schwab, facilitates this for you.
- The share price of an ETF can diverge from the Net Asset Value (“NAV”) of the investments in the portfolio. Open-end funds, commonly referred to as mutual funds, are bought and sold at NAV, as the portfolio proportionally expands or contracts to meet demand.
- IRC Section 351 for corporations and Section 721 for partnerships.
- SEC Rule 6c-11; IRC Section 852(b)(6).
- A “step-up in basis” happens when the cost basis of an asset held by a decedent is reset to the current value as of the date of death. The effect of this is eliminating capital gains on the asset. This is separate from estate tax and requires that the decedent own the asset at death.
- Income over $200,000, or $300,000 jointly with a spouse or partner, in each of the last two years, with the same expected this year. Or net worth over $1 million, alone or jointly, excluding the primary residence. Or certain financial licenses held in good standing.
- An individual or family company with $5 million or more in investments. Entities with $25 million or more in investments.
Important disclosures
Brightward Financial LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor in the State of Colorado that provides investment advisory services, financial planning, and wealth management to individuals and businesses. Advisory services are offered only to clients and prospective clients where Brightward Financial LLC and its representatives are properly registered or exempt from registration. Nothing in this article should be construed as a solicitation or offer to sell advisory services in any jurisdiction where Brightward Financial LLC is not registered or exempt.
This material is provided for informational and educational purposes only and should not be construed as tax, legal, or investment advice, or as a recommendation to buy or sell any security or pursue any strategy. Brightward Financial does not provide tax or legal advice; individuals should consult a qualified tax or legal professional regarding their specific circumstances. The information presented reflects our understanding of current law and IRS guidance as of the date of publication, which may change, in some cases retroactively. Exchange funds and other private placements are available only to eligible investors, involve risks including illiquidity, lock-up periods, and potential loss of principal, and are offered only by prospectus or offering memorandum. Brightward Financial is a registered investment adviser registered with the State of Colorado. Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training.
This article may contain forward-looking statements, including earnings estimates, price targets, valuations, and projected financial results. Actual results may differ materially from those anticipated, and forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance.
All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Index returns are unmanaged, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not available for direct investment.
Information in this article is sourced from publicly available data believed to be reliable but not independently verified. Brightward Financial LLC makes no representation or warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy, completeness, or timeliness.
Brightward Financial LLC and its principals, employees, or affiliates may hold long or short positions in securities mentioned here, and any such positions held at the time of publication are disclosed in the relevant content. Brightward Financial LLC does not accept compensation from any company mentioned in this article in exchange for favorable coverage or commentary.
Brightward Financial LLC’s Form ADV Part 2A and Part 2B describe our advisory services, fees, and material conflicts of interest in greater detail. Both are available upon request and at adviserinfo.sec.gov.


