Our October newsletter is later than normal, but for a few good reasons: a lot has happened at Brightward and in the markets in recent weeks.
Updates from Brightward
- Our new website is live at www.brightwardfinancial.com. It was months in the making, and we hope clients and prospective clients find it useful today and as we continue to post new white papers and other content.
- Ben passed the Certified Financial Planner (CFP®) exam. He enjoyed being a student again while preparing for his first major exam since the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) Level III in 2009.
- We launched Brightward Global Opportunities, a concentrated 20-stock portfolio of businesses with durable competitive advantages. It’s available only to Brightward clients and at no additional cost. We’ll share more about the strategy in future newsletters.
Market update: the AI trade turns four
On November 30, 2022, OpenAI released ChatGPT. Within 2 months, it had 100 million monthly users, growing faster than any consumer app before it. The following May, Nvidia reported a blowout quarter, and the AI boom was on.
Since then, the Nasdaq has returned ~140% (roughly 25% per year), but the AI trade has hit turbulence over the last six weeks. With many AI market leaders 25% to 40% below their previous high, we see three driving headwinds.
Headwind 1: The Nvidia scandal
Jensen Huang’s storied run as Nvidia’s co-founder and CEO ended November 12 when he stepped down under pressure from his board following reports of several scandals, including an affair with a suspected Chinese spy. The scandal could stop here, but the investigations are just getting started. As the old saying goes, “There’s never just one cockroach.”
No company has mattered more to the AI story. Nvidia supplies the chips used to train and run AI models. They are also active investors in their customers. In somewhat circular logic, Nvidia funds the sector through customers buying those chips.
Questions we’re asking:
- Did Nvidia or Huang knowingly violate or circumvent Export Administration Regulations? If so, how much of the company’s sales are connected to the violation?
- Did the company or its board mislead investors or the government?
- The government had this intelligence months, or maybe even years ago. Who leaked classified information, and why now?
- Is there civil or criminal liability?
- Who becomes the permanent CEO, and can anyone fill a role this big at a company this centralized?
- Under new leadership, do strategy and culture change? Will Nvidia rethink financing its own customers?
- Will the company be able to retain key talent in the wake of a charismatic founder’s departure?
To size the damage, we built a basket of the 40 largest AI-driven stocks (hyperscalers, semiconductors, power producers, etc.). From November 6 through November 11, Nvidia fell 7% while the basket rose 11%. On a relative basis, this means that Nvidia gave up nearly $1 trillion in market value. Looking further, the AI trade has been moving beyond Nvidia for a while, with Nvidia down 10% vs. the basket up 46% over the last twelve months.
Nvidia’s chip capacity is sold out through 2027, so there is little near-term risk to its financials. But the situation remains fluid, especially looking to 2028 and beyond. Some have observed that Apple succeeded after Steve Jobs and see a potential parallel with Nvidia. We’re not sure if that’s the right analogy. Apple transitioned from innovation to supply chain and financial optimization. Nvidia is the market leader today only because it is a fierce innovator. If they stop pushing the frontier, peers will catch up quickly. It’s a high-risk investment right now, not a slam dunk like many pundits contend. It could deliver outsized returns from these levels, or it could lose its edge and never regain the old highs.

Headwind 2: Voters hate data centers
Opposition to data centers was a key issue in the Democrats’ sweeping midterm win. 40 of 41 local ballot measures across ten states went against data centers. It’s become a rare bipartisan issue, with 70% of Democrats and 57% of Republicans supporting limits to data center construction in a September poll.
Texas was the big one. Governor-elect Gina Hinojosa (Democrat) ran and won on a platform that highlighted a moratorium “on all data center approvals until the Legislature can pass laws.”
Some of this is ordinary NIMBY1. But there is a widespread fear that data centers drain local power and water, enrich elites at the expense of the working class, and (possibly) endanger humanity.
Headwind 3: Neocloud debt
Neoclouds are cloud providers built for AI (CoreWeave is the best-known example). They buy or lease fleets of Nvidia chips, house them in data centers, and rent the computing power to LLM2 companies, enterprises, or the hyperscalers themselves.
They are also a weak link in the AI ecosystem. A neocloud is effectively a finance company with few competitive advantages, making money on the spread between what the chips cost and what they rent for. It works in a boom and goes bankrupt when things slow (think of all the Airbnb slum lords who were overextended going into Covid).
Compared to equity markets, the debt markets care much more about math than narrative. And they are skeptical. Until recently, neoclouds could borrow just slightly above a typical junk bond (9% and 7%, respectively). After the Fed raised rates again, investors now demand 15% or more to hold neocloud debt. This is distressed-debt territory, and the neocloud model doesn’t work when their borrowing costs are that high.
The historical analog
Some investors think the bull market is over and a 2000-style crash comes next. We think it’s missing a few key aspects.
The internet boom, bubble, and bust ran for roughly seven years (December 31, 1994 to December 31, 2001). The AI boom started on December 31, 2022, a month after ChatGPT launched. At 970 trading days, the internet-era Nasdaq was up 140%. At the same point today, the AI-era Nasdaq is up 142%. The paths have been remarkably similar.

During the internet boom, the Nasdaq climbed another 180% before peaking in March 2000 (571% from the start) and succumbing to an epic crash. Over the seven years, the Nasdaq rose 159% (an annualized 15%), while an investor who bought on day 970 ended 2001 up just 8%.
People who say this is a 2000 moment don’t have it quite right. Recent price returns, valuations, and the general level of hype don’t support the parallel: Nvidia trades around 12x earnings, and Cisco, its counterpart in 2000, peaked at well over 100x. This has been a hated bull market from the start, and people were calling it a 2000-style bubble as early as 2024.
We wouldn’t read the chart as a forecast. The match with 1995 through 1998 is probably just an interesting coincidence, and we see no reason to expect the next 3 years to track 1999 through 2001.
The big risk: concentrated demand
The most worrying fact about the AI story is how narrow its revenue base remains. Hundreds of millions of people use AI. Yet Ramp’s spending data shows that the top 1% of companies account for 80% of business spending on OpenAI and Anthropic. 80% of that top 1% still rely on venture capital to fund their operations [1][2]. Maybe they’re early adopters, and usage will spread. For now, the biggest buyers of compute are paying with venture money. If funding tightens, the effect will ripple across public markets.
Our positioning
Given these headwinds, we don’t see AI sentiment turning euphoric anytime soon. A full 1999-style bubble is unlikely.
Counterintuitively, that may be the bull case: low multiples, widespread skepticism, and rising debt costs are dampers on what could have become a speculative frenzy. Slower growth can be more durable growth. And as regulation makes new data centers harder to build, existing ones are worth more.
Our view: stay invested, diversified and disciplined. We’d avoid the extremes of risk-on and risk-off and use this moment to “high-grade” portfolios, favoring the highest-quality businesses, many of which are down in price. Even those may see more selling in the near term, but we expect them to emerge stronger on the other side.
Definitions
- NIMBY: Not In My Back Yard
- LLM: Large Language Model
References
[1] Ramp AI Index
[2] Circularity in AI Shows Up in Token Spending Too | The Daily Spark
Important disclosures
Brightward Financial LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor in the State of Colorado that provides investment advisory services, financial planning, and wealth management to individuals and businesses. Advisory services are offered only to clients and prospective clients where Brightward Financial LLC and its representatives are properly registered or exempt from registration. Nothing in this article should be construed as a solicitation or offer to sell advisory services in any jurisdiction where Brightward Financial LLC is not registered or exempt.
This article is provided for general informational purposes only and should not be considered personalized investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Opinions expressed are those of Brightward Financial LLC as of the date of publication and are subject to change without notice.
This article may contain forward-looking statements, including earnings estimates, price targets, valuations, and projected financial results. Actual results may differ materially from those anticipated, and forward-looking statements are not guarantees of future performance.
All investments involve risk, including the potential loss of principal. Past performance is not indicative of future results. Index returns are unmanaged, do not reflect the deduction of fees or expenses, and are not available for direct investment.
Information in this article is sourced from publicly available data believed to be reliable but not independently verified. Brightward Financial LLC makes no representation or warranty, express or implied, as to its accuracy, completeness, or timeliness.
Brightward Financial LLC and its principals, employees, or affiliates may hold long or short positions in securities mentioned here, and any such positions held at the time of publication are disclosed in the relevant content. As of the date of publication, Brightward Financial LLC and/or its principals hold long positions in Micron, Microsoft, Meta and NVDA. Brightward Financial LLC does not accept compensation from any company mentioned in this article in exchange for favorable coverage or commentary.
Brightward Financial LLC’s Form ADV Part 2A and Part 2B describe our advisory services, fees, and material conflicts of interest in greater detail. Both are available upon request and at adviserinfo.sec.gov.



